Mat Cashman and I did a teach-in session to a large audience of conference-goers who use options. Here’s one idea from that session.
The simplest way to understand the value of buying an option for directional reasons is to benchmark it to the counterfactual: how do I perform relative to “if I just bought the stock?”
If you buy a call, you do better in the large up move OR the large down move vs just buying the stock. You have more upside leverage, and if the stock craters, you only lose your premium. The tradeoff is that the option strategy underperforms owning the shares on intermediate-sized moves. That’s why we say owning an option is “long volatility” even if someone resists thinking in such admittedly abstract terms.
The chart subtracts the P/L of 100 shares from the P/L of ~2.2 calls on the 1-year 110 strike, at expiry. The calls cost $2,194 and carry the same delta as shares that cost $10,000 (100 shares of a $100 stock).
🔨Exercise: Solve for what delta the calls are
The shares win between roughly $78 and $137. The gap is widest at $110, where the calls expire worthless and the shares are up $1,000, a $3,200 difference. Below $78, the calls lose $2,194 at most while the shares keep falling. Above $110 the calls behave like 217 shares instead of 100.
If you buy a call and lose your premium, you can’t evaluate if this is a good or bad outcome without considering the counterfactual.
This was one of the examples I discussed in the live stream session where we talked about combining sources of data to reason through trade ideas.
Finally, an analogy I didn’t make at the conference, but notice how much like poker the chain of thought is. The cards you can see (ie the flop) are the measurables like IV rank or call skew. The quantity of options purchased is the bet size. The expiry is like thinking about the position they bet from (ie “under the gun” or right after the button to last position or “dealer”). One of the market-makers’ advantages is that they keep tabs on notable flow, like a poker bot which examines online players’ hand histories and tendencies.
a little exercise in proportion Here’s a way to think about options that has nothing…
There's No Such Thing as a Stock-Market Bubble | 4 min read Last week, Jeff…
In this issue: More AI uses to learnThe resolution of uncertainty is…bearish?Pricing put protection without…
🎙️Philip and Alan Maymin, co-heads of global asset allocation at Janus Henderson, joined Corey Hoffstein…
In light of midterms, or really the midterm avalanche on social media from all sides,…
In this issue: gerrymandered thoughtsLevine braincommodity index“stock pickers” market? Friends, In light of midterms, or…