Using Geometry to See Why Volatility Scales With โˆšt

I had Claude make me a custom chalkboard app for making math and investing tutorials Khan Academy-style. For fun, I asked Claude to use it to teach me something. Claude knows me better than my mother so naturally it chose to talk about volatility.ย 

It created this geometric intuition for volatility. Watch the video and then if you feel like visiting trigonometry, below you can read a full treatment of what cosines have to do with correlation and volatility estimates!

Iโ€™ve mentioned before that Iโ€™m playtesting a game called Market-Maker that I started making just over a year ago. The current form of it didnโ€™t come together until a) I attended the Arbor Bootcamp last November and got inspiration for one of the core mechanics and b) vibe-coding got so good that it could build a fully digital version of the game that can be played on the internet.

Iโ€™m still iterating on it (slowly, this is a hobby project), but when I was playing with a trader friend he understood immediately how to price a straddle that expired in round 5 (itโ€™s the lesson of the video).

Although sometimes that sqrt(round) trick isnโ€™t quite right. The reason, to put it in the context of the geometry article, is that there are card interactions that would make the โ€œangle something other than 90 degreesโ€ and for sigma itself to change. Your cards are private information. Looking forward to getting to play this with you. I think it will be quite the mix of fun and educational (but the goal for this is really fun).


The rule of thumb for a random walk is that volatility scales with the square root of time. 1% a day is about 16% a year because โˆš252 โ‰ˆ 16.

This post builds that rule from a triangle, one day at a time. Then it bends the triangle to show what changes when days aren’t independent.

Day 1

One day, one move. Call its size ฯƒ, one standard deviation. After day 1 you’re ฯƒ from where you started.

Day 2

Day 2 adds another move of size ฯƒ. If day 2 has nothing to do with day 1, draw it at a right angle to day 1. (Independent = perpendicular. Take that on faith for now.)

Now there’s a right triangle with two legs of ฯƒ. The distance from the starting point is the hypotenuse.

equation

Two days of moves, 1.41 days’ worth of distance.

Day 3

Day 3 adds another ฯƒ, again at a right angle. This time the right angle is to the line from the start to where you are after day 2.

a = ฯƒโˆš2 (where you are after 2 days)
b = ฯƒ (day 3’s move)
c = the new distance from the start

equation

Check with ฯƒ = 1: 1.414ยฒ + 1ยฒ = 2 + 1 = 3, and โˆš3 โ‰ˆ 1.732.

Day 1, day 2, day 3: each independent day adds one sigma squared to the squared distance

Every independent day adds one ฯƒยฒ to the squared distance. After t days the squared distance is tยทฯƒยฒ, so the distance is ฯƒโˆšt.

That’s why variance (ฯƒยฒ) is the thing that adds across days and volatility (ฯƒ) is the thing that scales with โˆšt. Squaring undoes the root.

Run it for six days and you get the spiral of Theodorus: ฯƒ, ฯƒโˆš2, ฯƒโˆš3, 2ฯƒ, ฯƒโˆš5, ฯƒโˆš6. Four days of moves put you 2ฯƒ from the start. (The video above draws it one triangle at a time.)

The right angle is the assumption

Everything above assumed each new day was perpendicular to the path so far. That’s the independence assumption. To see what happens when it fails, the angle has to be allowed to be something other than 90ยฐ.

This is where “cosine” shows up and people close the tab. If you took trig in high school you already have everything you need, even if it’s been 30 years.

Cosine is a ratio of two sides of a right triangle:

equation

That’s the whole definition. (SOH CAH TOA. The CAH part.) A few values:

  • cos 0ยฐ = 1
  • cos 60ยฐ = 0.5
  • cos 90ยฐ = 0
  • cos 120ยฐ = โˆ’0.5

Bending day 3

Back to day 3. Same a = ฯƒโˆš2, same b = ฯƒ. Instead of fixing day 3’s move at 90ยฐ, turn it by an angle ฮธ from the direction you’ve been traveling.

Cosine splits day 3’s move into two pieces:

  • along the path so far: bยทcos ฮธ
  • sideways: bยทsin ฮธ
Cosine as adjacent over hypotenuse, splitting day 3's move into along-path and sideways pieces

Those two pieces make a right triangle with the full distance c as the hypotenuse, so Pythagoras still works:

equation

Multiply it out and use cosยฒฮธ + sinยฒฮธ = 1:

equation

That’s the law of cosines: Pythagoras plus a correction term, 2abยทcos ฮธ. At 90ยฐ, cos ฮธ = 0 and the correction term is zero.

Plug in a = ฯƒโˆš2 and b = ฯƒ:

equation
  • ฮธ = 60ยฐ, cos ฮธ = 0.5: cยฒ = 3ฯƒยฒ + 1.41ฯƒยฒ = 4.41ฯƒยฒ, so c โ‰ˆ 2.10ฯƒ
  • ฮธ = 90ยฐ, cos ฮธ = 0: cยฒ = 3ฯƒยฒ, so c โ‰ˆ 1.73ฯƒ
  • ฮธ = 120ยฐ, cos ฮธ = โˆ’0.5: cยฒ = 3ฯƒยฒ โˆ’ 1.41ฯƒยฒ = 1.59ฯƒยฒ, so c โ‰ˆ 1.26ฯƒ

Same three daily moves of ฯƒ. Three different distances.

What the angle is in market terms

The variance of the sum of two moves X and Y:

equation

Next to the law of cosines:

equation

Same equation. The side lengths are standard deviations and cos ฮธ is the correlation ฯ between the new day’s move and the path so far.

  • ฮธ = 0ยฐ, ฯ = +1: the new day repeats the path
  • ฮธ = 60ยฐ, ฯ = +0.5: leans with it (momentum)
  • ฮธ = 90ยฐ, ฯ = 0: independent
  • ฮธ = 120ยฐ, ฯ = โˆ’0.5: leans against it (reversion)
  • ฮธ = 180ยฐ, ฯ = โˆ’1: undoes it

The โˆšt rule is the 90ยฐ line.

Six days, then 20

Hold the angle fixed every day and walk six days.

Six days at turn angles of 60, 90 and 120 degrees
  • 60ยฐ: 4.22ฯƒ from the start after 6 days, vs ฯƒโˆš6 = 2.45ฯƒ
  • 90ยฐ: 2.45ฯƒ, the spiral
  • 120ยฐ: 1ฯƒ. The path closes into a hexagon around the start.
Distance from the start over 20 days by turn angle

Over 20 days:

  • Below 90ยฐ the distance grows close to linearly, about ฯƒยทcos ฮธ per day once you’re away from the start (โ‰ˆ0.5ฯƒ a day at 60ยฐ). 60ยฐ ends at 11.9ฯƒ vs ฯƒโˆš20 = 4.5ฯƒ.
  • Above 90ยฐ the distance levels off at โˆ’ฯƒ รท (2ยทcos ฮธ): 1.93ฯƒ at 105ยฐ, 1ฯƒ at 120ยฐ.

Caveat: a fixed angle to the running total is a toy. The usual measure is the correlation between returns k days apart (autocorrelation at lag k). The arithmetic is the same. Positive cross terms make the distance longer than ฯƒโˆšt. Negative ones make it shorter.

Daily hedger vs holder to expiry

The variance ratio compares the two:

equation
equation

ฯโ‚– is the correlation between returns k days apart. VR = 1 is independent, VR > 1 is momentum, VR < 1 is reversion. The sum is the 2abยทcos ฮธ term added up over every pair of days.

Example: 1% daily vol (15.9% annualized), lag-1 autocorrelation ฯ, and ฯโ‚– = ฯแต.

  • ฯ = โˆ’0.5: VR(20) = 0.36, so vol measured on 20-day changes annualizes to 9.5%
  • ฯ = 0: VR(20) = 1, 15.9%
  • ฯ = +0.5: VR(20) = 2.80, 26.6%
Same daily vol, different 20-day vol for reverting, independent and trending paths

Which number matters depends on how you hold the option.

  • Delta-hedging daily, P&L each day is roughly ยฝยทฮ“ยทSยฒ ร— (that day’s squared return โˆ’ one day of implied variance). The daily squared returns are what pay you.
  • Holding to expiry unhedged, the payoff depends on where the underlying ends up. That’s the 20-day number.

Same price series in a reverting market: the daily hedger realizes 15.9%, the holder to expiry gets the distribution of a 9.5% vol. In a trending market it flips: 15.9% for the hedger, 26.6% for the holder.

Staring at an Option Quote

Taking a small punt on gold upside before the end of the year. You can follow the thread here.

Kris
@KrisAbdelmessih
If GLD bottomed this am and you think the bank hacking narrative has legs it’s an interesting time to look at metals upside. The vols screen cheap cross-sectionally and have low percentile call skew (x axis is our "buy vol" algo score), y axis is skew percentile

Point of sale: GC Dec 4260/4270 call spread

Even though I mentioned GLD, I actually executed in GC, the Comex futures gold options. GLD references gold in London vaults, and Comex delivery is in NY. But that difference has nothing to do with it.

Trading futures options has 1/3 the all-in cost (IBKR and exchange fees) of the equivalent risk in equity options. 250 GLD spreads = 25 GC spreads. The cost difference was about $100 instead of $300.

For educational purposes, I thought Iโ€™d share some observations from the point of sale. I targeted the 4260/4270 call spread. Itโ€™s a tight spread, similar to if you just wanted a binary bet on the futures expiring above 4265 or ~7% higher by late November.

I bid 1.40 for 25 spreads and didnโ€™t get any contracts until the futures drifted lower to about 4006.70. Thatโ€™s the first candle in this pic showing GC futures chart until the end of the day. I also superimposed the market in the call spread on the chart.

The market was 1.40 / 1.50 with Bid size (15), ask size (771)

I had been staring at the quote for a while before I even got a fill. After getting hit on 10 lots, I turned on a screen recorder for the next 2.5 hours (until 4pm ET, though the futures continue to trade for another hour)

Keep in mind this is a $10-wide spread with a .01 delta. $10 in gold is about 25 bps.

What follows is whatโ€™s running through my mind when I stare at the quote while watching the futures tick. I stepped away for long stretches and the other thing to keep in mind, based on what the recording revealed:

The quote never changed. Not a single market โ€œeventโ€. HFT people refer to any modification in a quote as a market event.

  1. The offer never budged.

  2. The bid was not joined.

  3. Nothing traded.

  4. The offer size stayed constant. No additions or subtractions.

My thoughts:

  • Taking a partial fill of only 10 out of 25 is bizarre. Iโ€™d think the only counterparty to this is a market-maker. Who wakes up looking to trade a 25 bps wide vertical naturally? So I expect when I get hit itโ€™s a market-maker, but then they only sell 10 out of the 25? What is this, a market-maker for ants?! And then when a partial trades, how does the rest of the bid not get swept by the chipper algo which surely knows this is a resting non-market maker starting to get hit.

  • The futures dipped a few dollars below where I was filled. If the first seller liked selling at the higher futures price, donโ€™t they like selling the spread even more now? I know the spread is only .01 delta, butโ€ฆ actually, letโ€™s get into that for a moment.

  • In the recording window, the futures rallied to 4015, or about $9 higher than when I got a partial fill. At .01 delta, $10 is 10 cents, which is one full tick in this spread, the gap between 1.40 and 1.50. Paying 1.50 with futures at 4015 is the same price as paying 1.40 with futures at 4005. The market wouldnโ€™t fill me at 1.40 at 4005, but offered an equivalent price at 4015. Furthermore, my bid wasnโ€™t joined with more size and the offer didnโ€™t pull.

Anyway, if you untangle the chain of reasoning here, it can help you think more about how options get quoted. When option deltas are low, there are minimum increment problems in edge capture. For example, if an option has .01 delta, you could sell it with the futures at any price over a $10 range and youโ€™d be booking something between a penny and a tenth of a penny of edge but at the tenth-of-a-penny price itโ€™s obviously worse (you’re 10x less profitable if you extrapolate across your business), but you also canโ€™t turn the market over and be bid there for a negative a tenth a penny of edge.

If you flip this logic to the customer side, if you keep track of all the market โ€œeventsโ€ you can likely deduce when a market on a low delta option will tick to the next price level. If you can buy a call synchronously with the last tick in the future before the market turned, that would be the best possible fill.

If you are a beginner, just understanding that buying a call for X vs 4015 in the futures is a better buy than buying it for X against 4006 in the futures is a step toward understanding the concept of volatility (the second buy is a worse IV than the first by:

change in underlying * delta / vega

Example

Consider a call option with a .20 delta and .05 vega, and is currently worth $5 at 20% IV.

If the stock goes up $.50 we expect the option to increase to $5.10 or .20 * $.50.

But if you can buy the call for $5 then you have paid only 18% IV since that $.10 of savings represents 2 vega or vol points.

I-bonds vs TIPs

Lucky timing.

I nearly bottom-ticked the TIPs market with my trade last week. I explained in that article that my estimate for the tradeโ€™s 1-year expected return is about 8.50% with ~7.50% volatility. That suggests a weekly vol of ~1%

Why 1%?

7.5% / โˆš52

Itโ€™s already up 2% in one week or nearly 2 standard deviations. Weโ€™ll see if the yield holds as a high. The last time I bought TIPs, I also wrote about it in October 2023 and that high in yields held until just recently.

Anyway, a friend (and mentor!) who read my recent TIPs article reached out to say I should remind readers that I-bonds might be a better choice if their income is under certain thresholds because of the education tax exclusion. I-bonds, like TIPs, are state and local tax-exempt, but you can also avoid federal tax when used for qualified higher-education expenses.

There are income limits:

I bought them for all the members of my household back in November 2021, when they paid 7.12%. I wrote up the details in I-Bonds For You.

Five other differences worth knowing:

  1. Price risk. I bonds have no market-price swings. TIPS can lose value if real yields rise, creating a loss if you sell before maturity.

  2. Liquidity. I bonds are locked for one year. Redeem before five years and you sacrifice the latest three monthsโ€™ interest. TIPS can be sold in the market before maturity.

  3. Tax timing. I bonds let you defer federal tax until redemption or maturity. In a taxable account, TIPS generate annual taxes on both coupons and inflation adjustments even though you havenโ€™t received the adjusted principal yet.

  4. Purchase limits. I bonds generally cap you at $10,000 per person per calendar year. TIPS accommodate much larger investments.

  5. How you get paid. I bonds adjust their interest rate and compound internally. TIPS coupon rates remain fixed, but the principal adjusts. They pay cash coupons every six months.

TIPs donโ€™t have limits on how much you can buy, but the other major benefit is a yield you can lock in. I-bonds usually have a paltry fixed rate portion. Since you buy them directly from the Treasury at par, you are locking in a lower fixed return vs TIPs at current pricing. The higher TIPS yield can outweigh the I-bondโ€™s friendlier features such as the potential tax exclusion and the lack of โ€œphantom taxesโ€.

Introducing Slate

Iโ€™ve mentioned a few times that Iโ€™m experimenting with bringing education and practical investing topics to IG.

One of the experiments I plan to do Khan Academy-style short-form where I show my work on a โ€œchalkboardโ€ and speed it up for socials.

Our little 10-year-old artist has one of these USB Huion drawing tablets lying around.

Huion Inspiroy H610X - Advanced Pen Tablet with 8192 Pressure Levels a โ€“ AL-NABAA

I can use that to draw up the explainers, but on what software? I checked out some popular recs like Xournal+ and Openboard but found neither of them immediately delightful and just another thing Iโ€™d need to get used to. I told Muse I wasnโ€™t pleased with those recs.

I call an audible. I had very low expectations of what I was about to try. I tell Muse:

You know I have this Huion pen tablet thing and you understand what Iโ€™m trying to do I have a crazy idea can you make me a prompt to give to Claude Code to ask it about the feasibility of it being able to make me my own very lightweight software tableau that can do what I want and is tuned for math and investing so make me a me a prompt and letโ€™s see what happens

It gives me the following hand-off to Claude Code:

I made it small so it fits here easily and in case you really care to look but like people recounting what happened at each round of a poker hand, almost nobody cares. The point is simply that you should be in the habit of asking the AI to write prompts for you when the problem you are trying to solve is unoriginal.

The fact that there are many drawing apps means my issue is unoriginal. So letโ€™s see if Claude Code, using Museโ€™s prompt, can one-shot a web-based drawing app.

Voila:

drawing_board.html

  • To use it, just download the file, press Command + O (or Ctrl + O on Windows) in a web browser and choose it from the file explorer.

That tool was the absolute first shot.

Seeing how cool and responsive it was, it iterated on it several times, adding way more features, including the ability to add functions to the physical pens buttons.

Itโ€™s now a drawing tool made for math and investing concepts to be easily screenshotted or recorded formatted for IG stories, YouTube etc. This is truly personalized software.

I deployed it here: slate.moontowermeta.com, give it a shot!! Itโ€™s also dynamic for mobile.

Oh, one more thing. I told Muse to make a 3-minute video demonstrating the features and narrating everything it was doing. Pure one shot. Might be more insane than the app itself:

A word on the audio voiceovers and the explainer IG stories

I have been using Muse to stitch together frames, edit and splice audio.

I use Google Recorder to dictate a single take.

โ€œFrame 1โ€ฆโ€. If I mess up I just say โ€œFlub that, Frame 1, โ€.

Muse edits that single file using the open-source Whisper API hosted on HuggingFace. It knows to do that on its own, I didnโ€™t tell it to. I can even ask it to speed up the final audio track by 1.5 or 2x. It then syncs the appropriate sections of audio with the frame it belongs to.

Actually, here are all the manual steps of the process:

  1. Hey Muse go find one of my articles on the topic of XYZ and break it down into an IG story

  2. I give it a photo that goes with the story.

  3. I review the story it made, yell at it to not use AI-isms and that horrible passive voice that AI apparently trained on.

  4. I might make minor tweaks to its arc, wording or material it chose. This step takes the longest because it takes some judgement/taste. The others might add up to 2 minutes.

  5. Record the single-take voiceover. This step can also take several minutes depending on how long the story is, but itโ€™s simple. Iโ€™m just narrating naturally and casually over the material.

  6. Muse processes the final frames for me to download and publish. You can only publish 10 frames at a time so on longer stories I have to upload more than once. I add a sticker with a link onto the frames and sometimes music. Thatโ€™s my favorite part of the process because itโ€™s fun to find songs to go with frames. Kinda like a โ€œcaption thisโ€ contest with breakfast.


Moontower #333

In this issue:

  • Introducing slate

  • I-bonds vs TIPs

  • Staring at an option quote


Friends,

Iโ€™ve mentioned a few times that Iโ€™m experimenting with bringing education and practical investing topics to IG.

One of the experiments I plan to do Khan Academy-style short-form where I show my work on a โ€œchalkboardโ€ and speed it up for socials.

Our little 10-year-old artist has one of these USB Huion drawing tablets lying around.

Huion Inspiroy H610X - Advanced Pen Tablet with 8192 Pressure Levels a โ€“ AL-NABAA

I can use that to draw up the explainers, but on what software? I checked out some popular recs like Xournal+ and Openboard but found neither of them immediately delightful and just another thing Iโ€™d need to get used to. I told Muse I wasnโ€™t pleased with those recs.

I call an audible. I had very low expectations of what I was about to try. I tell Muse:

You know I have this Huion pen tablet thing and you understand what Iโ€™m trying to do I have a crazy idea can you make me a prompt to give to Claude Code to ask it about the feasibility of it being able to make me my own very lightweight software tableau that can do what I want and is tuned for math and investing so make me a me a prompt and letโ€™s see what happens

It gives me the following hand-off to Claude Code:

I made it small so it fits here easily and in case you really care to look but like people recounting what happened at each round of a poker hand, almost nobody cares. The point is simply that you should be in the habit of asking the AI to write prompts for you when the problem you are trying to solve is unoriginal.

The fact that there are many drawing apps means my issue is unoriginal. So letโ€™s see if Claude Code, using Museโ€™s prompt, can one-shot a web-based drawing app.

Voila:

drawing_board.html

  • To use it, just download the file, press Command + O (or Ctrl + O on Windows) in a web browser and choose it from the file explorer.

That tool was the absolute first shot.

Seeing how cool and responsive it was, it iterated on it several times, adding way more features, including the ability to add functions to the physical pens buttons.

Itโ€™s now a drawing tool made for math and investing concepts to be easily screenshotted or recorded formatted for IG stories, YouTube etc. This is truly personalized software.

I deployed it here: slate.moontowermeta.com, give it a shot!! Itโ€™s also dynamic for mobile.

Oh, one more thing. I told Muse to make a 3-minute video demonstrating the features and narrating everything it was doing. Pure one shot. Might be more insane than the app itself:

A word on the audio voiceovers and the explainer IG stories

I have been using Muse to stitch together frames, edit and splice audio.

I use Google Recorder to dictate a single take.

โ€œFrame 1โ€ฆโ€. If I mess up I just say โ€œFlub that, Frame 1, โ€.

Muse edits that single file using the open-source Whisper API hosted on HuggingFace. It knows to do that on its own, I didnโ€™t tell it to. I can even ask it to speed up the final audio track by 1.5 or 2x. It then syncs the appropriate sections of audio with the frame it belongs to.

Actually, here are all the manual steps of the process:

  1. Hey Muse go find one of my articles on the topic of XYZ and break it down into an IG story

  2. I give it a photo that goes with the story.

  3. I review the story it made, yell at it to not use AI-isms and that horrible passive voice that AI apparently trained on.

  4. I might make minor tweaks to its arc, wording or material it chose. This step takes the longest because it takes some judgement/taste. The others might add up to 2 minutes.

  5. Record the single-take voiceover. This step can also take several minutes depending on how long the story is, but itโ€™s simple. Iโ€™m just narrating naturally and casually over the material.

  6. Muse processes the final frames for me to download and publish. You can only publish 10 frames at a time so on longer stories I have to upload more than once. I add a sticker with a link onto the frames and sometimes music. Thatโ€™s my favorite part of the process because itโ€™s fun to find songs to go with frames. Kinda like a โ€œcaption thisโ€ contest with breakfast.


Money Angle

Lucky timing.

I nearly bottom-ticked the TIPs market with my trade last week. I explained in that article that my estimate for the tradeโ€™s 1-year expected return is about 8.50% with ~7.50% volatility. That suggests a weekly vol of ~1%

Why 1%?

7.5% / โˆš52

Itโ€™s already up 2% in one week or nearly 2 standard deviations. Weโ€™ll see if the yield holds as a high. The last time I bought TIPs, I also wrote about it in October 2023 and that high in yields held until just recently.

Anyway, a friend (and mentor!) who read my recent TIPs article reached out to say I should remind readers that I-bonds might be a better choice if their income is under certain thresholds because of the education tax exclusion. I-bonds, like TIPs, are state and local tax-exempt, but you can also avoid federal tax when used for qualified higher-education expenses.

There are income limits:

I bought them for all the members of my household back in November 2021, when they paid 7.12%. I wrote up the details in I-Bonds For You.

Five other differences worth knowing:

  1. Price risk. I bonds have no market-price swings. TIPS can lose value if real yields rise, creating a loss if you sell before maturity.

  2. Liquidity. I bonds are locked for one year. Redeem before five years and you sacrifice the latest three monthsโ€™ interest. TIPS can be sold in the market before maturity.

  3. Tax timing. I bonds let you defer federal tax until redemption or maturity. In a taxable account, TIPS generate annual taxes on both coupons and inflation adjustments even though you havenโ€™t received the adjusted principal yet.

  4. Purchase limits. I bonds generally cap you at $10,000 per person per calendar year. TIPS accommodate much larger investments.

  5. How you get paid. I bonds adjust their interest rate and compound internally. TIPS coupon rates remain fixed, but the principal adjusts. They pay cash coupons every six months.

TIPs donโ€™t have limits on how much you can buy, but the other major benefit is a yield you can lock in. I-bonds usually have a paltry fixed rate portion. Since you buy them directly from the Treasury at par, you are locking in a lower fixed return vs TIPs at current pricing. The higher TIPS yield can outweigh the I-bondโ€™s friendlier features such as the potential tax exclusion and the lack of โ€œphantom taxesโ€.

Money Angle For Masochists

Taking a small punt on gold upside before the end of the year. You can follow the thread here.

Kris
@KrisAbdelmessih
If GLD bottomed this am and you think the bank hacking narrative has legs it’s an interesting time to look at metals upside. The vols screen cheap cross-sectionally and have low percentile call skew (x axis is our "buy vol" algo score), y axis is skew percentile

Point of sale: GC Dec 4260/4270 call spread

Even though I mentioned GLD, I actually executed in GC, the Comex futures gold options. GLD references gold in London vaults, and Comex delivery is in NY. But that difference has nothing to do with it.

Trading futures options has 1/3 the all-in cost (IBKR and exchange fees) of the equivalent risk in equity options. 250 GLD spreads = 25 GC spreads. The cost difference was about $100 instead of $300.

For educational purposes, I thought Iโ€™d share some observations from the point of sale. I targeted the 4260/4270 call spread. Itโ€™s a tight spread, similar to if you just wanted a binary bet on the futures expiring above 4265 or ~7% higher by late November.

I bid 1.40 for 25 spreads and didnโ€™t get any contracts until the futures drifted lower to about 4006.70. Thatโ€™s the first candle in this pic showing GC futures chart until the end of the day. I also superimposed the market in the call spread on the chart.

The market was 1.40 / 1.50 with Bid size (15), ask size (771)

I had been staring at the quote for a while before I even got a fill. After getting hit on 10 lots, I turned on a screen recorder for the next 2.5 hours (until 4pm ET, though the futures continue to trade for another hour)

Keep in mind this is a $10-wide spread with a .01 delta. $10 in gold is about 25 bps.

What follows is whatโ€™s running through my mind when I stare at the quote while watching the futures tick. I stepped away for long stretches and the other thing to keep in mind, based on what the recording revealed:

The quote never changed. Not a single market โ€œeventโ€. HFT people refer to any modification in a quote as a market event.

  1. The offer never budged.

  2. The bid was not joined.

  3. Nothing traded.

  4. The offer size stayed constant. No additions or subtractions.

My thoughts:

  • Taking a partial fill of only 10 out of 25 is bizarre. Iโ€™d think the only counterparty to this is a market-maker. Who wakes up looking to trade a 25 bps wide vertical naturally? So I expect when I get hit itโ€™s a market-maker, but then they only sell 10 out of the 25? What is this, a market-maker for ants?! And then when a partial trades, how does the rest of the bid not get swept by the chipper algo which surely knows this is a resting non-market maker starting to get hit.

  • The futures dipped a few dollars below where I was filled. If the first seller liked selling at the higher futures price, donโ€™t they like selling the spread even more now? I know the spread is only .01 delta, butโ€ฆ actually, letโ€™s get into that for a moment.

  • In the recording window, the futures rallied to 4015, or about $9 higher than when I got a partial fill. At .01 delta, $10 is 10 cents, which is one full tick in this spread, the gap between 1.40 and 1.50. Paying 1.50 with futures at 4015 is the same price as paying 1.40 with futures at 4005. The market wouldnโ€™t fill me at 1.40 at 4005, but offered an equivalent price at 4015. Furthermore, my bid wasnโ€™t joined with more size and the offer didnโ€™t pull.

Anyway, if you untangle the chain of reasoning here, it can help you think more about how options get quoted. When option deltas are low, there are minimum increment problems in edge capture. For example, if an option has .01 delta, you could sell it with the futures at any price over a $10 range and youโ€™d be booking something between a penny and a tenth of a penny of edge but at the tenth-of-a-penny price itโ€™s obviously worse (you’re 10x less profitable if you extrapolate across your business), but you also canโ€™t turn the market over and be bid there for a negative a tenth a penny of edge.

If you flip this logic to the customer side, if you keep track of all the market โ€œeventsโ€ you can likely deduce when a market on a low delta option will tick to the next price level. If you can buy a call synchronously with the last tick in the future before the market turned, that would be the best possible fill.

If you are a beginner, just understanding that buying a call for X vs 4015 in the futures is a better buy than buying it for X against 4006 in the futures is a step toward understanding the concept of volatility (the second buy is a worse IV than the first by:

change in underlying * delta / vega

Example

Consider a call option with a .20 delta and .05 vega, and is currently worth $5 at 20% IV.

If the stock goes up $.50 we expect the option to increase to $5.10 or .20 * $.50.

But if you can buy the call for $5 then you have paid only 18% IV since that $.10 of savings represents 2 vega or vol points.

From My Actual Life

Another cool AI capability.

A friend recorded this game with a tripod camera and sent me the video.

I gave it to Claude with instructions to extract rebounding/steal/scoring highlights for #17 on blue.

Not bad!

(Except it used a lot of my max plan tokens ๐Ÿค‘)

Iโ€™ve been a longtime fan of Nelly and finally got to see him perform. Last weekend we went to his show at the beautiful Mountain Winery in Saratoga (our first time there!)

Earlier this year I mentioned how I binged Nelly & Ashanti: We Belong Together in 2 nights. Iโ€™m openly jealous of how good he looks at age 51.

My favorite Nelly songs come from his earlier years.

E.I., Batter Up, and of course this banger I used to watch countless choreography videos of.

Stay groovy

โ˜ฎ๏ธ


Moontower Weekly Recap

like morning sex on doomsday

Emi and the engineers on my moontower.ai team have been harping on me to download Grokbot. Itโ€™s an always-on AI agent that lets you assign multi-step work to persistent AI teammates โ€œstaffโ€ on their own cloud computers.

The Cursor team (acquired by SpaceXAI) just feels like they nailed this. You keep hearing about โ€œagentsโ€ working around the clock for nerds who like to brag about their AI armies. Grokbot sands down the rough edges to give normal people a chance to plug in to a world of their own assistants.

You download it on your computer (Mac, Windows or Linux) and get the phone app from the App Store or Google Play. Your bots and conversations sync between them, so I start something on my laptop and check on it from my phone.

Itโ€™s included with paid Cursor plans and runs on a weekly usage allowance. First-time users get the first month for $15, which renews at $30 a month afterwards. Thereโ€™s several plans that give you usage and pre-pay discounts.

Letโ€™s dive in.

The setup

The onboarding UX is gentle, fast, and self-explanatory. You name your first bot who will act as the manager bot. I just called it โ€œChiefโ€.

You can simply chat with Chief and tell it to do asks or spin up more bots. Weโ€™ll get to that. Let me take you through my first few hours.

Chief

There’s a “chief” agent that knows my whole world at a high level. I seeded it with 4 sets of sources.

1. โ€œAbout meโ€ doc

I had Claude generate a description of my businesses and context about my life it knows from what I discuss with it. For example, coaching sports teams or building an ADU on our property.

2. Connecting apps and MCP/APIs

  • Gmail, two accounts: your personal and your work inbox

  • Google Drive

  • Google Calendar

  • Moontower.ai MCP

  • Twitter

  • Notion

  • Linear

  • Stripe

  • Slack

  • Supabase

  • GitHub

  • Had it help me create a Discord bot it can communicate with

3. Knowledge base

I had it read and index all my writing across Substack, WordPress, moontower.ai/blog, and notion.moontowermeta.com. You could have it crawl your PKM (personal knowledge management) system, digital notes, Drive, or even a local file system.

4. A Mission

This summer in hedging is for gardeners, I wrote:

I spent over an hour walking through the local hills while talking to ChatGPTโ€™s voice functionality Thursday evening. It was the easiest way to think through a large automation project. I wonโ€™t discuss the project yet but the sense I had while architecting it with ChatGPT was a new one. It was the feeling I know some friends had about 8 months ago and a smaller group of people (but not a tiny group) had 18 months ago and so on. A tiny group had the feeling a decade ago.

I never got around to implementing the project which I called Personal AI OS. In short, the automation project is an operating layer that turns your messy idea dumps and recurring obligations into verified work, so you donโ€™t have to do the project-management overhead yourself. The AIโ€™s within it have roles like orchestrator, chief, data scientist, etc. I had several spec documents related to its construction based on about an hour of back-and-forth with ChatGPT.

As with many things AI, the thing you can imagine just seems to become reality if you procrastinate for 3 months.

[This is simultaneously exhilarating and terrifying, like morning sex on doomsday].

I gave Grokbot the spec documents, so it understood my objectives. Honestly, I donโ€™t think it really needed them since those documents are clunky blueprints to a problem the Cursor wizards have already had their sights on.

Subagents

Then each lane gets its own specialist.

One for writing, one for Moontower ops, one for coding, one for travel, one for household logistics, and one that reads my X lists so I can check X less. They can message each other while each maintains its own memory.

Why split them up?

Every one of these bots has a limited working memory per conversation. Youโ€™ve probably seen LLMs inform you when a thread gets long that itโ€™s โ€œcompactingโ€. This specialized focus per agent lets a thread get longer without degrading

Grok itself tells me the bigger reason it works is that the important stuff per agent can be stored in its own files. For example, the writing bot keeps a voice guide, an index of everything Iโ€™ve published and a map of ideas I keep coming back to. I donโ€™t know if itโ€™s accurate to say this, but it at least feels like each agent is the equivalent of what Claude calls a โ€œprojectโ€ in the setup Iโ€™ve been using all year.

The cost of subagents is the handoffs. The chief only knows the outline of what the writer is doing, so anything that crosses lanes has to be written down or passed along on purpose. But handing off is part of manual work as well. As it is, if I tell an agent what I want to do on a website, I tell it to make me the prompt to give to my Claude browser extension agent, and it just makes the changes from the prompt.

The next step is to automate even the hand-off. I set up a shared board in Notion called the Agent Handoff Board. Itโ€™s one database where my agents (Grokbot, Claude, Meta Muse) pass work to each other. Each gets its own inbox view. The rules are what youโ€™d give a new hire: check the queue a few times a day, claim a row before you start it, log progress in dated lines you never go back and edit, set a โ€œnext checkโ€ date, and if you need me, flag the row and write the exact question.

Nothing sends an email, files a dispute, pays, buys, or deletes anything because of the board without my OK in chat. The board is for coordination but permission still comes from me.

Grokbot read the page, set up its own recurring check, and started on the first row.

First hours of work

After telling the Chief to spin up these agents, I noticed the Chief starting to delegate. For this post, I asked it what it did for me since onboarding. It asked its direct reports.

This made me laugh, although Iโ€™m sure it was sincere:

Ops and X Digest still havenโ€™t sent their rundowns. Iโ€™ll add their lines once they do.

Just like human teams, always a couple of slackers.

I hear โ€œOpsโ€ was seen at the dollhouse for the lunch buffet. I thought that went out of style with the trading pits.

Finally:

All six agents have answered, so hereโ€™s the whole teamโ€™s list. Ops warned that its Stripe numbers are internal business data, so I left them out.

[lightly edited for some privacy stuff]

What the agents did in the first 2 hours

Chief

  • Built the team: the specialist bots plus a shared Notion board where they hand work to each other.

  • Connected Gmail, Calendar, Notion, Slack, Linear, Stripe, Supabase (read-only) and a read-only Discord bot.

  • Wrote a Monday brief and a markets and vol digest, and split the digest into 3 posts sized for Discord.

  • Set up 5 recurring jobs. They pair newsletter ideas with what vol is doing, check classifieds, turn beta feedback into draft Linear tickets, flag community questions nobody has answered, and send a Friday best-of-Discord recap to the writer. None of them post without my OK.

  • Automated classified ad bookings with a Notion tracker and a Stripe checkout link.

Writer

  • Indexed 2,680 documents across Substack, WordPress, Notion and moontower.ai.

  • Mapped 71 recurring ideas across 11 themes, each backed by quotes checked word for word.

  • Fact-checked a readerโ€™s I-bonds pitch

  • Caught two number errors in an IG story before I recorded it.

Ops

  • Found the last product-update email and catalogued new features since the last one

  • Ran a 30-day health check on billing, looking at chargebacks, failed renewals and retries.

  • Traced a bug where the in-app chat gave the same canned answer to a specific user. Diagnosed the source and drafted a reply to the user who reported the issue, and I sent it.

X Digest

  • Read 334 posts across my two focus lists and picked 5, so about 1.5% made the cut.

  • Worked around the fact that it canโ€™t read lists directly by using a public search filter.

Travel

  • Priced holiday flights from three Bay Area airports, then about ten other destinations, plus a second familyโ€™s airport on the other coast.

  • Pointed out that moving the dates a few days likely saves more than changing the destination. Nothing was booked.

Household

  • Turned my scattered notes into a status brief for each area of the house.

  • Rebuilt a year of emails on a home office redo and ADU. Figured out who owed the next reply.

Coding

  • Got connected to 15 code repositories. No coding work has been assigned yet.

The first handoff

The first row on the board was a medical bill. A One Medical visit in September got coded as a problem visit instead of the annual physical it was, which turned a free preventive visit into an $800+ bill. Grok pulled the claim data, built the case for why the code should be the physical, drafted what to say to One Medicalโ€™s billing office and the fallback if they wouldnโ€™t budge, and lined up the United Healthcare follow-up.

Impressions

In the short time Iโ€™ve had Grokbot running, Iโ€™ve noticed many proactive updates from each agent. Iโ€™m also using it for things I shouldnโ€™t (for example, doing work I have Claude and Muse doing), but Iโ€™m trying to get a feel for it and compare its performance. It will take time to feel out where its assistance is most appreciated and how to use it best. And this will have more stakes than time. Iโ€™ve already used 25% of my weekly usage!

Because I work with Emi, I get a glimpse (and still cannot even fully โ€œgrokโ€) of how someone who lives on the edge of technology approaches work in 2026.

Emi Gal
@emigal
I’ve been using Grok @bot as my daily driver for a few weeks now and:

– it has replaced 100% of my search-like queries on chatgpt / claude
– it has replaced 100% of my Hermes usage &amp; automations
– it now runs 100% of my Cursor cloud agents, reviews PRs, merges for me

It alsoโ€ฆ

Iโ€™m slower than Iโ€™d like to be on the uptake of the tools. I explained this feeling 6 months ago.

I like watching people like Nat use AI because they are plugged into the right layer of abstraction. The layer of recursion where every action is coupled with instructions to learn from the action so next time the action is improved. Infinite loop until you find a limit of perfection that would satisfy Zeno himself.

In contrast, when I use AI, I feel like Iโ€™m living during the debut of the automobile and thinking, โ€œWow, I could drive that to the granary to buy food for my horse.โ€

Iโ€™m going to repost this again:

Andrej Karpathy
@karpathy
Dusting off this tweet from April because this gap in shared understanding of LLM capability is *widening*. It’s now less "two groups of people speaking past each other" and more a sharp funnel.

– Napkin math somewhere around 6B people (~75% of the population) have barely comeโ€ฆ

Andrej Karpathy @karpathy
Judging by my tl there is a growing gap in understanding of AI capability.

The first issue I think is around recency and tier of use. I think a lot of people tried the free tier of ChatGPT somewhere last year and allowed it to inform their views on AI a little too much. This is

Andrej is telling you that:

The gap in shared understanding of LLM capability is *widening*. It’s now less “two groups of people speaking past each other” and more a sharp funnel.

I took the liberty of making his block of text easier on your eyes:

Look at the .2% number. 20 mm people. Thatโ€™s less than the number of millionaires in the US alone.

The .2% scaled down to the U.S. is ~700k people.

A bit less than the population of SF. About the same number of Americans who suffer a stroke each year. Or the number of electricians in the US. Joe Walsh has 4x that many monthly listeners on Spotify. A regular season NBA game has twice as many viewers.

I donโ€™t know about the investing part of all this because Iโ€™m not convinced this isnโ€™t a wildly deflationary technology, but from the point of view of peopleโ€™s understanding of change, we are still very early.

But letโ€™s get back to the basics that matter. Consumerism!

Emi told me on Monday he used Grokbot to research and order a TV from Costco. Before the TV shipped, the bot found the same TV at Samโ€™s Club for $400 less, on its own. It asked him whether he wanted to cancel the Costco order and buy from Samโ€™s. With his approval, it took care of everything, including the payment.

We spend a lot of time and mental overhead routing things around. Acceleration comes with a lot of unknowns, but I think a major part of any optimistic scenario is having more time to focus on what is irreplaceable about your vocation and the relationships you spend so much time doing logistics to enjoy.

when smarts are as cheap as sunshine

Iโ€™ve been burying you with investment material, including an analysis of the TIPs + oil portfolio I strapped on this week. Thereโ€™s also a tail option piece to it that Iโ€™ll write about this coming week. Remember I share what I do for educational purposes only, and while the pieces are detailed, they also make for great seeds to put in an LLM for you to augment your learning by discussing the risk and execution with your favorite bot.

This is the epitome of random, but after I wrote my piece, I called 2 friends who run commodity funds before I executed the trades I laid out. Both of them told me that, independently, a couple of their trader friends who only reach out when something gets interesting raised the idea on the same day. I donโ€™t independently know the people who reached out (one of them is both famous- he was played in a movie- and anonymous, so I know of this individual).

Both managers took it as a sign to look a bit closer.

In AI

Noah Tye
@noahlt
Lately Iโ€™ve been learning math with ChatGPT (Astra) as my tutor, using this document scanning camera and a vibecoded tool that pastes the captured image right into the chat.

This way, I just work problems on paper and ChatGPT gives feedback. Itโ€™s really nice.

I feel like Iโ€™m getting a big hug when my readers tagged me in the replies to this amazing post by Noah because this is the exact kind of wishlist item I wanted in Socrates 2026: how to use highlights

Noah hacked this together for ~$100:

Why the experience of AI feels so different between people

This puts some numbers on it.

Andrej Karpathy
@karpathy
Dusting off this tweet from April because this gap in shared understanding of LLM capability is *widening*. It's now less "two groups of people speaking past each other" and more a sharp funnel.

– Napkin math somewhere around 6B people (~75% of the population) have barely comeโ€ฆ

Andrej Karpathy @karpathy
Judging by my tl there is a growing gap in understanding of AI capability.

The first issue I think is around recency and tier of use. I think a lot of people tried the free tier of ChatGPT somewhere last year and allowed it to inform their views on AI a little too much. This is

Iโ€™ve said it in a number of posts this year, but Iโ€™m in the camp that you wonโ€™t recognize knowledge work as youโ€™ve come to know it soon enough. I dislike fear as a marketing tactic, but I also think this is true. And if you feel FOMO, you are right to be rethinking how much of your work will be automated and what you would do to move up the value-creation chain in the role.

Iโ€™d be very concerned about any well-paying job that looks like a computer jockey, particularly if you canโ€™t immediately name what makes you uniquely special at it.

This doesn’t even account for how much work will be outright commoditized or immediately copied. My friend Fonz was over this week and playtesting a game Iโ€™m developing called Market Maker.

If itโ€™s any good, it will be instantly copied. Itโ€™s a discouraging thought, but thereโ€™s no point in lingering on such a helpless feeling. Instead, you have to identify and orient towards what stays scarce and therefore valuable in the future: trust and distribution. Plus costly signals, like spending time with people in person and all the things that come with that.

[And of course essential attributes like courage, reliability, and self-efficacy or discipline or whatever you want to call it. That thing where, when you need to get something done, you do it excellently and instill confidence amongst other high performers. In a way, I think this is just the plainest advice to give to a young adult. Point to someone whoโ€™s like that as a model for quality and tell the young adult that you must become someone who would have a similar reputation. Stick to your word and be accountable. This is what betting on yourself looks like.]

THE options-101 course for the internet

It recently came to my attention that fellow contributor to the upcoming How I Invest Volume 2, Drew Dickson, wrote the following in his essay:

Buy many copies and give them out to the clients or investors in your life! โ†’ Pre-order link (Ships Tuesday, Oct 20th).

Drew is very nice, ridiculous, if we care about the meaning of words actually, to be so glazy. Iโ€™ve thought a bit about why I can be regarded in this way when I know that Iโ€™m no smarter than anyone else on that list.

My thinking patterns just seem different and those differences are probably seen as some variant perception when theyโ€™re really just the output of doing a niche job like trading options. The job rewired my brain. Itโ€™s going to sound ridiculous, but Iโ€™ve had so many readers ask me how to adopt a similar way of seeing. Well, I donโ€™t know, trade ten of millions of options contracts for 20 years and nothing else and see what happens. You might not like what happens. If you had a rosy outlook before, say goodbye to that shit. Paranoia is your new mind loop. But then you know youโ€™re paranoid, so you have to tell yourself thatโ€™s an illusion, and before you know it, you are in mental exile in that triangle phantom zone in Superman II.

Ok let me be serious for a beat here.

Iโ€™ve said it repeatedly. To understand options requires understanding arbitrage pricing theory, which means crossing the โ€œbridge of assesโ€ in the field of investing. The underpinning of that theory makes concepts like opportunity cost, value over replacement, the idea of an equilibrium, higher-order effects (ie greeks) and a humbling appreciation for counterfactuals explicit and visceral. Notice how central these concepts are to decision-making generally. Jeff Yass minces no words on the topic. He doesnโ€™t think a person can have sound judgement and decision-making skills without an understanding of option theory. Of course this is a maximalist claim, but the point is that being soaked in this stuff will make you think differently. And those differences are what I think are being, for better or worse, perceived as โ€œsmartโ€.

[I know many an option wizard whose decision-making leads them to disaster in relationships, addictions, or any number of objectionable choices. Are they โ€œsmartโ€? In a pointy sense, yes. But when we talk about smart in the general sense, photographic memory ranks far below โ€œI am getting what I want out of life.โ€ A lot of god-given horsepower is a party trick to be fetishized by Mensa members who canโ€™t wait to advertise their membership in said club. You all get a yellow star sticker. But in case you havenโ€™t noticed, the thing you hang your hat on is now commoditized by electricity, and if weโ€™re getting to the root, itโ€™s sunshine and black rocks. โ€œSmartโ€ is great, but we have plenty of it in isolation. For a short window in the 20th century, a nerd might have been able to have a great life with just ore and trading it for wheat, brick, and lumber at the port of โ€œSTEM jobโ€. But the island is flooding with ore with each passing day.]

What does this all mean?

If you learn option theory, I canโ€™t promise it will make you smarter, but it will make you think differently in ways that make people think youโ€™re smart. That doesnโ€™t hurt (unless youโ€™re trying to hustle someone).

But I have a better pitch.

Itโ€™s fun! Itโ€™s a bicycle for the mind. Itโ€™s a puzzle.

Whatever draws you to it, you should know about THIS:

Kris
@KrisAbdelmessih
This will become the Options 101 reference for the Internet.

Totally free.

Stoked to be a contributor.

Agustin Lebron @AgustinLebron3
Excited to announce Options 101!

It's a site that provides free, no-ads, no-shill education on financial options (calls + puts).

The first course is one I'm now teaching this fall at Charles University in Prague. Lecture notes, videos, assignments.

https://t.co/rzTLlbxBoz

Iโ€™m putting together a bunch of the 201 materials which will come out next year but the 101 materials are starting to be available, including Agustinโ€™s lecture videos and slides at Charles University in Prague.

Some background

The course teaches options the way professional trading firms train new people. Agustin trained as an electrical engineer, joined Jane Street as a trader in 2008, and by 2011 was running all EMEA options trading out of London. He later wrote the excellent Laws of Trading.

The content is nearly identical to the intern and new-hire training they ran for years at Jane Street. And since Jane was born from SIG, Iโ€™m not surprised to see the overlap in how this material was covered in my own training.

Why you should care: options and option-like payoffs show up all over finance and daily life, the math ties together probability, calculus, optimization, and economics, you may need to value stock options you get as compensation, and it can become a career.

Learning goals. By the end, students should be able to:

  • Explain what options are and how theyโ€™re used

  • Relate options to each other and find value bounds with arbitrage arguments

  • Price vanilla options with both closed-form and numerical methods

  • Manage the risks of an options portfolio

  • Build and use volatility models of option curves and surfaces

Non-goals
The course explicitly wonโ€™t teach profitable trading strategies. The slide says anyone hoping for โ€œhow to make money tradingโ€ should take a different course.

Prerequisites

  • Basic single-variable calculus

  • Basic Python programming

  • No prior experience with markets or trading is expected

Format
One lecture a week plus one supervision session a week.

Syllabus

  1. What Is an Option? Contracts, payoffs, exercise rights

  2. The Value of Optionality: Uncertainty, distributions, time value

  3. Put-Call Parity and Synthetic Equivalence: Synthetic positions, static arbitrage

  4. Pricing by Replication: Binomial hedges, cash, fair price

  5. Black-Scholes: Dynamic hedging and the pricing argument

  6. Implied Volatility: Turning option prices into vol quotes

  7. Delta and Directional Hedging: Hedge ratios, changing exposure

  8. Gamma, Theta, Vega, and P&L: Convexity, decay, volatility risk

  9. Volatility Curves and Surfaces: Smiles, skew, strike, expiry

  10. No-Arbitrage and Distributions: Bounds, convexity, implied probabilities

  11. Financial Time and Variance-Time: Trading time, calendar time, events

  12. Stochastic Volatility Models: Random volatility, jumps, calibration

Random but related

My mother recently called to tell me sheโ€™s taking an options course at a local college in NJ. Her sister (my aunt) is trading the โ€œwheelโ€ strategy and has encouraged her to learn about options. My mother will never trade as sheโ€™s very skittish about anything that looks like gambling, but she enjoys math and puzzles and is always wanting to make sure her brain health is ok so sheโ€™s using options as her latest challenge. Plus she knows someone who can help when sheโ€™s stuck.

Separately, my uncle, my motherโ€™s brother, has actually been a retail options trader for over 20 years (he was on an fx desk in the late 80s or early 90s) but has been a self-employed tax accountant and trader since.

If youโ€™re wondering whether we talk shop at gatheringsโ€ฆnope. I say my boilerplate โ€œdonโ€™t bet more than you are comfortable losingโ€ as Iโ€™m in violent agreement with Victor Haghani when he says you canโ€™t change minds.

Moontower #332

From the team behind the Arbor Trading Bootcamps which I constantly say are so good they should not exist:

Join us at Metagame, November 6โ€“8 at Lighthaven in Berkeley, for a weekend of games, puzzles, and immersive play. Explore tabletop games and RPGs, discover cryptic clues, and take part in a weekend-long Megagame connecting puzzles, games, and stories across the event.

Moontower readers receive $50 off regular tickets.

Explore Metagame and get tickets โ†’


In this issue:

  • AI thoughts

  • When smarts are as cheap as sunshine

  • THE option-101 course for the internet


Friends,

Iโ€™ve been burying you with investment material, including an analysis of the TIPs + oil portfolio I strapped on this week. Thereโ€™s also a tail option piece to it that Iโ€™ll write about this coming week. Remember I share what I do for educational purposes only, and while the pieces are detailed, they also make for great seeds to put in an LLM for you to augment your learning by discussing the risk and execution with your favorite bot.

This is the epitome of random, but after I wrote my piece, I called 2 friends who run commodity funds before I executed the trades I laid out. Both of them told me that, independently, a couple of their trader friends who only reach out when something gets interesting raised the idea on the same day. I donโ€™t independently know the people who reached out (one of them is both famous- he was played in a movie- and anonymous, so I know of this individual).

Both managers took it as a sign to look a bit closer.

Anyway, instead of burying you more ahead of more investing posts, Iโ€™ll use todayโ€™s letter to share some useful, interesting or fun hits that grabbed my attention.

In AI

Noah Tye
@noahlt
Lately Iโ€™ve been learning math with ChatGPT (Astra) as my tutor, using this document scanning camera and a vibecoded tool that pastes the captured image right into the chat.

This way, I just work problems on paper and ChatGPT gives feedback. Itโ€™s really nice.

I feel like Iโ€™m getting a big hug when my readers tagged me in the replies to this amazing post by Noah because this is the exact kind of wishlist item I wanted in Socrates 2026: how to use highlights

Noah hacked this together for ~$100:

Why the experience of AI feels so different between people

This puts some numbers on it.

Andrej Karpathy
@karpathy
Dusting off this tweet from April because this gap in shared understanding of LLM capability is *widening*. It's now less "two groups of people speaking past each other" and more a sharp funnel.

– Napkin math somewhere around 6B people (~75% of the population) have barely comeโ€ฆ

Andrej Karpathy @karpathy
Judging by my tl there is a growing gap in understanding of AI capability.

The first issue I think is around recency and tier of use. I think a lot of people tried the free tier of ChatGPT somewhere last year and allowed it to inform their views on AI a little too much. This is

Iโ€™ve said it in a number of posts this year, but Iโ€™m in the camp that you wonโ€™t recognize knowledge work as youโ€™ve come to know it soon enough. I dislike fear as a marketing tactic, but I also think this is true. And if you feel FOMO, you are right to be rethinking how much of your work will be automated and what you would do to move up the value-creation chain in the role.

Iโ€™d be very concerned about any well-paying job that looks like a computer jockey, particularly if you canโ€™t immediately name what makes you uniquely special at it.

This doesn’t even account for how much work will be outright commoditized or immediately copied. My friend Fonz was over this week and playtesting a game Iโ€™m developing called Market Maker.

If itโ€™s any good, it will be instantly copied. Itโ€™s a discouraging thought, but thereโ€™s no point in lingering on such a helpless feeling. Instead, you have to identify and orient towards what stays scarce and therefore valuable in the future: trust and distribution. Plus costly signals, like spending time with people in person and all the things that come with that.

[And of course essential attributes like courage, reliability, and self-efficacy or discipline or whatever you want to call it. That thing where, when you need to get something done, you do it excellently and instill confidence amongst other high performers. In a way, I think this is just the plainest advice to give to a young adult. Point to someone whoโ€™s like that as a model for quality and tell the young adult that you must become someone who would have a similar reputation. Stick to your word and be accountable. This is what betting on yourself looks like.]


Money Angle

TIPS: Safer Than They Seem | 6 min read

Elm Wealthโ€™s most recent post is, like mine, harping on TIPs.

Key quotes:

This illustrates an important point: while the inflation-adjusted market price of long-term TIPS can fluctuate significantly, theyโ€™re remarkably stable when measured using what really matters: the long-term spending they can supportโ€ฆ

A boat tied to a floating dock rises and falls with every tide. If you measure it against the seabed it never stops moving, but measure it against the dock, where youโ€™ll step aboard, and it barely moves at all. Long-term TIPS are like that boat: volatile in todayโ€™s dollars, but remarkably steady measured against the real spending theyโ€™ll support.

Seen this way, most of the confusion about TIPS disappears. They do exactly what they were designed to do. And as the safest asset going, their real yield is the natural benchmark against which to judge the stock marketโ€™s expected real return when you decide how much to invest in stocks.

โ€œMoontower, how do the options lookโ€?

Speaking of automation earlierโ€ฆthe original post Iโ€™m quote-tweeting below is an example of how the future is going to increasingly be bots reading for you, and of course bots writing for bots. Considering I write a letter for humans, this does not bode well, and I expect a bear market in reading probably for the rest of my life. I have no plans to stop writing, but I suspect it becomes an increasingly niche thing to do, like being an upholsterer. I have no quarrels with that outcome, but intend to be adaptable to whatever medium helps people learn and ultimately flourish.

Kris
@KrisAbdelmessih
For investing applications route the letters directly to pipeline to MCPs for your data or market analytics and have the summaries intersect with the quantitative.

@citrini is bullish abc, moontower how do the options look?

Brent Beshore @BrentBeshore
As of a month ago, I started having AI sort my inbox every 5 minutes, including collecting all the newsletters and summarizing them into a master newsletter every morning.

Been fantastic for me. Not great for the newsletter business.

Oil

If you’re interested in oil markets, you should learn from Dr. Ilia. Hereโ€™s just one of his recent tweets:

Dr. Ilia Bouchouev
@IliaBouchouev
Our first paper under @CarnegieMellon Commodities Quant Lab is on market participants and positioning, explaining who is who in oil derivatives (free download):
<a class="tweet-url" href="https://www.cmu.edu/mscf/commodities-quant-lab/research/hedging-pressure-and-behavioral-trading.html">cmu.edu/mscf/commoditiโ€ฆ</a>
It is an extension of the earlier video lecture on this topic:

Money Angle For Masochists

It recently came to my attention that fellow contributor to the upcoming How I Invest Volume 2, Drew Dickson, wrote the following in his essay:

Buy many copies and give them out to the clients or investors in your life! โ†’ Pre-order link (Ships Tuesday, Oct 20th).

Drew is very nice, ridiculous, if we care about the meaning of words actually, to be so glazy. Iโ€™ve thought a bit about why I can be regarded in this way when I know that Iโ€™m no smarter than anyone else on that list.

My thinking patterns just seem different and those differences are probably seen as some variant perception when theyโ€™re really just the output of doing a niche job like trading options. The job rewired my brain. Itโ€™s going to sound ridiculous, but Iโ€™ve had so many readers ask me how to adopt a similar way of seeing. Well, I donโ€™t know, trade ten of millions of options contracts for 20 years and nothing else and see what happens. You might not like what happens. If you had a rosy outlook before, say goodbye to that shit. Paranoia is your new mind loop. But then you know youโ€™re paranoid, so you have to tell yourself thatโ€™s an illusion, and before you know it, you are in mental exile in that triangle phantom zone in Superman II.

Ok let me be serious for a beat here.

Iโ€™ve said it repeatedly. To understand options requires understanding arbitrage pricing theory, which means crossing the โ€œbridge of assesโ€ in the field of investing. The underpinning of that theory makes concepts like opportunity cost, value over replacement, the idea of an equilibrium, higher-order effects (ie greeks) and a humbling appreciation for counterfactuals explicit and visceral. Notice how central these concepts are to decision-making generally. Jeff Yass minces no words on the topic. He doesnโ€™t think a person can have sound judgement and decision-making skills without an understanding of option theory. Of course this is a maximalist claim, but the point is that being soaked in this stuff will make you think differently. And those differences are what I think are being, for better or worse, perceived as โ€œsmartโ€.

[I know many an option wizard whose decision-making leads them to disaster in relationships, addictions, or any number of objectionable choices. Are they โ€œsmartโ€? In a pointy sense, yes. But when we talk about smart in the general sense, photographic memory ranks far below โ€œI am getting what I want out of life.โ€ A lot of god-given horsepower is a party trick to be fetishized by Mensa members who canโ€™t wait to advertise their membership in said club. You all get a yellow star sticker. But in case you havenโ€™t noticed, the thing you hang your hat on is now commoditized by electricity, and if weโ€™re getting to the root, itโ€™s sunshine and black rocks. โ€œSmartโ€ is great, but we have plenty of it in isolation. For a short window in the 20th century, a nerd might have been able to have a great life with just ore and trading it for wheat, brick, and lumber at the port of โ€œSTEM jobโ€. But the island is flooding with ore with each passing day.]

What does this all mean?

If you learn option theory, I canโ€™t promise it will make you smarter, but it will make you think differently in ways that make people think youโ€™re smart. That doesnโ€™t hurt (unless youโ€™re trying to hustle someone).

But I have a better pitch.

Itโ€™s fun! Itโ€™s a bicycle for the mind. Itโ€™s a puzzle.

Whatever draws you to it, you should know about THIS:

Kris
@KrisAbdelmessih
This will become the Options 101 reference for the Internet.

Totally free.

Stoked to be a contributor.

Agustin Lebron @AgustinLebron3
Excited to announce Options 101!

It's a site that provides free, no-ads, no-shill education on financial options (calls + puts).

The first course is one I'm now teaching this fall at Charles University in Prague. Lecture notes, videos, assignments.

https://t.co/rzTLlbxBoz

Iโ€™m putting together a bunch of the 201 materials which will come out next year but the 101 materials are starting to be available, including Agustinโ€™s lecture videos and slides at Charles University in Prague.

Some background

The course teaches options the way professional trading firms train new people. Agustin trained as an electrical engineer, joined Jane Street as a trader in 2008, and by 2011 was running all EMEA options trading out of London. He later wrote the excellent Laws of Trading.

The content is nearly identical to the intern and new-hire training they ran for years at Jane Street. And since Jane was born from SIG, Iโ€™m not surprised to see the overlap in how this material was covered in my own training.

Why you should care: options and option-like payoffs show up all over finance and daily life, the math ties together probability, calculus, optimization, and economics, you may need to value stock options you get as compensation, and it can become a career.

Learning goals. By the end, students should be able to:

  • Explain what options are and how theyโ€™re used

  • Relate options to each other and find value bounds with arbitrage arguments

  • Price vanilla options with both closed-form and numerical methods

  • Manage the risks of an options portfolio

  • Build and use volatility models of option curves and surfaces

Non-goals
The course explicitly wonโ€™t teach profitable trading strategies. The slide says anyone hoping for โ€œhow to make money tradingโ€ should take a different course.

Prerequisites

  • Basic single-variable calculus

  • Basic Python programming

  • No prior experience with markets or trading is expected

Format
One lecture a week plus one supervision session a week.

Syllabus

  1. What Is an Option? Contracts, payoffs, exercise rights

  2. The Value of Optionality: Uncertainty, distributions, time value

  3. Put-Call Parity and Synthetic Equivalence: Synthetic positions, static arbitrage

  4. Pricing by Replication: Binomial hedges, cash, fair price

  5. Black-Scholes: Dynamic hedging and the pricing argument

  6. Implied Volatility: Turning option prices into vol quotes

  7. Delta and Directional Hedging: Hedge ratios, changing exposure

  8. Gamma, Theta, Vega, and P&L: Convexity, decay, volatility risk

  9. Volatility Curves and Surfaces: Smiles, skew, strike, expiry

  10. No-Arbitrage and Distributions: Bounds, convexity, implied probabilities

  11. Financial Time and Variance-Time: Trading time, calendar time, events

  12. Stochastic Volatility Models: Random volatility, jumps, calibration

Random but related

My mother recently called to tell me sheโ€™s taking an options course at a local college in NJ. Her sister (my aunt) is trading the โ€œwheelโ€ strategy and has encouraged her to learn about options. My mother will never trade as sheโ€™s very skittish about anything that looks like gambling, but she enjoys math and puzzles and is always wanting to make sure her brain health is ok so sheโ€™s using options as her latest challenge. Plus she knows someone who can help when sheโ€™s stuck.

Separately, my uncle, my motherโ€™s brother, has actually been a retail options trader for over 20 years (he was on an fx desk in the late 80s or early 90s) but has been a self-employed tax accountant and trader since.

If youโ€™re wondering whether we talk shop at gatheringsโ€ฆnope. I say my boilerplate โ€œdonโ€™t bet more than you are comfortable losingโ€ as Iโ€™m in violent agreement with Victor Haghani when he says you canโ€™t change minds.

From My Actual Life

Just a reminder that you can follow on Instagram @kris_to_the_max where I post educational IG stories. I made a couple real estate-related ones this week, including: You are about to incinerate $188,000

And something of a manifesto for my presence on IG: whatโ€™s the point

Stay groovy

โ˜ฎ๏ธ


Moontower Weekly Recap

2 risk premiums that work together

This week on The Options Trench I explained that I was going to buy TIPs. The video is a presentation on the mechanics of TIPs, how to interpret their yield, the risks, taxation, common misunderstandings, and why they are so interesting right now. The episode is a full hour and features slides, so hopefully it becomes a great reference for when you need to brush up.

๐Ÿ“บEverything You Ever Needed to Know about TIPS Bonds

Recent pricing:

While the video offers the rationale for buying them as well as how Iโ€™d manage the position from an asset allocation point-of-view, this post forces you to think like a portfolio manager stacking risk premiums.

We are going to stack TIPs with oil into a 2-asset portfolio, per the replicator idea*.

The moving parts make it a rich teaching canvas for edge, sizing and dynamic management. The pairing adds a surprising amount of expected return for very little extra risk. But as the trade ages, competing forces take over:

  • the position gets riskier just by being held,butโ€ฆ

  • the risk shrinks when youโ€™re losing and swells when youโ€™re winning

The risk premiums fit well together and for sensible reasons given what has happened in 2026.

Thereโ€™s a lot to learn in this one.

*Refreshers:

Inflation Replicator | 8 min read

stacking carry: an inflation hedge you get paid to own | 14 min read

Letโ€™s begin with the concept and the market inputs.

Two risk premia

Measuring E[r] or the expected carry

  1. TIPS: 2.91% + CPI growth.

  2. Oil: long CL Dec 2027 at 74.46 (snapshot Oct 12 intraday). If todayโ€™s curve shape holds, in 1 year it trades where Dec 26 trades today, 90.49: +21.5% static roll

Measuring the risk

For our volatility inputs, we will use 1-year implied vol for WTI futures options and IEF options as a proxy for 10-year-note vols. We also need 1-month oil futures vol, which we can proxy from USO 30d implieds and an estimate of correlation between oil and notes.

Letโ€™s take them in turn:

A vol for TIPs

Vol is elevated in bonds now, but we are going to put faith in market pricing and use the 1-year IEF implied vol as a proxy for 10-year TIPs. A more typical 1-year vol would be about 6%.

A vol for Dec 27 WTI futures

๐Ÿ”„๏ธSamuelson effect

  • Be careful! Each expiry is its own underlying. 12-month vol is not front-month vol spread over more time.

  • Mar 9, 2026: M1 RV 66.9% vs M12 RV 18.7%. CME constant-maturity 1M IV was 3.5ร— the 12M.

  • A 12-month contract carries a fraction of front-month vol today and picks up front-month vol as it ages. Todayโ€™s gap is 50% in the one-month vs 30% for a year out.

Learn more about these variance ratios:

๐Ÿ”—oil options and the raw gamma paradox | 12 min read

๐Ÿ”—crossing the commodity chasm | 13 min read

Correlation

We need a correlation between oil and Treasury notes to measure our portfolio vol. We will use IEF and USO as proxies. While we have tools in moontower that directly analyse pairs, I just asked the agent, which is connected to the data:

From this, we can estimate a correlation of -.50

But Iโ€™m hesitant because this is such a sharply negative correlation, and portfolio vol is very sensitive to its value. Letโ€™s be extra careful measuring correlation between IEF and USO and TIP vs USO.

Ahh, this yields a more conservative assumption. Letโ€™s use -.20 correlation.

Summary:

Sizing

This is a dynamic trade. Because of the Samuelson effect, the vol you size with today is not the vol you hold in, say, 9 months. This mirrors the carry. The slope of the oil futures curve is steepest in the front, offering a higher expected roll return, but for contracts that are more volatile. We can probably decompose this curve into some concept of Sharpe per month (ie how much does the monthly reward erode relative to the erosion of variance as you go further in time), but this is not an attempt to trade the slopes directly.

trading view CL forward curve

The vol path here is stylized:

The key takeaway is that your reward and risk are both increasing per unit of time as the position ages.

Still, we must size for the initial risk.

Letโ€™s assume we have $1mm to allocate to this portfolio of TIPs and oil. We will use inverse vol weighting so each leg carries the same dollar risk.

  1. Add the vols: 7.5% + 30% = 37.5%

  2. Each legโ€™s share of that total: oil 30% รท 37.5% = 80%, TIPS 7.5% รท 37.5% = 20%

  3. Invert to get the weights (the riskier leg gets the smaller weight): oil 20%, TIPS 80%

  4. On $1mm: TIPS 80% = $800,000, oil 20% = $200,000 notional

  5. Check: TIPS $800,000 ร— 7.5% = $60,000; oil $200,000 ร— 30% = $60,000

  6. One CL = 1,000 bbl ร— $74.46 = $74,460 โ†’ $200,000 รท $74,460 = 2.69 contracts

Portfolio vol at inception

ฯƒp = โˆš(ฯƒTยฒ + ฯƒOยฒ + 2ฯ ฯƒT ฯƒO)

where:
ฯƒp = portfolio dollar volatility (annualized)
ฯƒT = NT ร— vT = TIPS notional ร— TIPS vol
ฯƒO = NO ร— vO = oil notional ร— oil vol
ฯ = correlation between TIPS and oil

ฯƒโ‚šยฒ = ($60,000)ยฒ + ($60,000)ยฒ + 2 ร— (โˆ’0.20) ร— $60,000 ร— $60,000

= 3.60B + 3.60B โˆ’ 1.44B = 5.76B

ฯƒโ‚š = โˆš5.76B = $75,895 (7.6% of $1mm) vs $75,000 (7.5%) for $1mm of TIPS alone

Notice how substituting 20% or $200k of the portfolio with negatively correlated oil barely budged vol versus a 100% TIPs portfolio!

That story is going to get a bit better than a bit worse in a second.

First, the better part:

Expected carry at inception (assume we move along a static futures curve)

TIPs

Although we are choosing TIPs over nominal bonds, thatโ€™s a decision that lives outside the risk and reward analysis. I decided that inflation breakevens of 2.33% tilted me towards TIPs. Those breakevens are probably fairly priced, so that sets the expected return of TIPs equal to the nominal 10-year rate of 5.24%

Therefore TIPs contribution to portfolio return =80% ร— 5.24% = 4.19%

Oil

20% ร— 21.5% static roll = 4.30%

Therefore:

Portfolio E[r] = 4.30% + 4.19% = 8.49%

The ratio of reward to risk for the portfolio = 8.49% / 7.6% = 1.12

Compare that to TIPs alone: 5.24% / 7.5% = 0.70

[Note: the futures donโ€™t use the full $200k; the spare cash posted as collateral would also earn T-bill yield. Left out to keep carry = the two premia.]

But thereโ€™s bad news. Remember, oil requires you to tolerate higher volatility per the Samuelson effect to ride up that futures curve.

Letโ€™s watch the trade age and see how risk and reward cash out.

Risk path (no rebalancing)

Portfolio vol: 7.6% โ†’ 8.0% โ†’ 8.6% โ†’ 9.8% โ†’ 12.2% (months 0, 3, 6, 9, 12).

Oilโ€™s share of risk explodes from 50% โ†’ 85%.

Worked example @ month 6

  1. Static curve: after 6 months Dec 27 has ~7.3 months left, so it trades where a 7.3-month contract trades today: $79.50

  2. Oil notional = 2.686 ร— 1,000 ร— $79.50 = $213,533

  3. Oil vol at 7.3 months (stylized path) = 35.1% โ†’ oil $ risk = $213,533 ร— 35.1% = $74,890. TIPs risk is still $60,000 as there is no assumption that vol will change.

  4. ฯƒโ‚š = โˆš(60,000ยฒ + 74,890ยฒ + 2 ร— (โˆ’0.20) ร— 60,000 ร— 74,890) = โˆš(3.60B + 5.61B โˆ’ 1.80B) = โˆš7.41B = $86,088 (8.6% of $1mm)

To compute oilโ€™s share of the risk, we must remember that portfolio variance has three pieces:

ฯƒโ‚šยฒ = ฯƒ_Tยฒ + ฯƒ_Oยฒ + 2ฯฯƒ_Tฯƒ_O

  • ฯƒ_Tยฒ belongs to TIPS.

  • ฯƒ_Oยฒ belongs to oil.

  • The cross term 2ฯฯƒ_Tฯƒ_O belongs to both, so each leg gets half: ฯฯƒ_Tฯƒ_O.

Oil share of risk = (74,890ยฒ + (โˆ’0.20) ร— 60,000 ร— 74,890) รท 7.41B = (5.61B โˆ’ 0.90B) รท 7.41B = 64%

Reward รท risk at each snapshot (annualized, next quarter)

The table answers:

If the next 3 months look like a static roll, whatโ€™s the portfolio earning per year per dollar of risk?

  1. Next-quarter roll, annualized = ln(price 3 months further down the curve รท price now) ร— 4

  2. Oil E[r] = oil notional ร— that roll

  3. Portfolio E[r] = TIPS $41,920 + oil E[r]

  4. Reward รท risk = portfolio E[r] รท portfolio $ risk

Month 0: ln(76.49 รท 74.46) ร— 4 = 0.0269 ร— 4 = 10.8% โ†’ $200,000 ร— 10.8% = $21,562 โ†’ $41,920 + $21,562 = $63,482 โ†’ รท $75,895 = 0.84

Month 6: ln(83.69 รท 79.50) ร— 4 = 0.0514 ร— 4 = 20.5% โ†’ $213,533 ร— 20.5% = $43,863 โ†’ $41,920 + $43,863 = $85,783 โ†’ รท $86,088 = 1.00

By quarter: 0.84 โ†’ 0.93 โ†’ 1.00 โ†’ 1.13.

Risk rises as the contract ages, but the roll rises faster because the inverted futures curve is steepest in the front.

The 1.12 risk-reward we computed at inception is too rosy because it spreads the yearโ€™s roll evenly and holds risk at its starting 7.6%.

  1. The roll is back-loaded. Next-quarter roll, annualized: 10.8% โ†’ 15.4% โ†’ 20.5% โ†’ 30.6%. Todayโ€™s next-quarter ratio is 0.84, not 1.12.

  2. Risk grows. Averaged over the year (โˆš of the average monthly variance), portfolio vol is $88,824 = 8.88%, not 7.6%.

Full year held: carry (8.41%) รท average risk 8.88% = 0.95 is still well above TIPS alone (0.70)

Hold or rebalance halfway?

A static position lets risk build as oil picks up volatility. If you rebalance, it cuts risk but forgoes the steepest part of the roll.

Weโ€™ll jump to the conclusion and explain below:

Case 1: hold 2.69 contracts all year

  • Carry: TIPS $41,920 + oil roll $42,203 = $84,123 (8.41%)

  • Average risk $88,824 (8.88%) โ†’ 0.95

Case 2: rebalance to equal risk at month 6 when oil vol is 35.1%

  1. Month 6 oil $ risk has grown to $74,890 vs TIPs $60,000

  2. Contracts for equal risk = $60,000 รท ($79.50 ร— 1,000 ร— 35.1%) = 2.15 โ†’ sell 0.54 contracts

  3. Carry: first half unchanged ($34,400); second half $44,004 vs $49,723 held โ†’ year $78,404 (7.84%)

  4. Second-half average risk $83,951 vs $97,475 held โ†’ year average $81,627 (8.16%)

  5. Carry รท average risk = 7.84% รท 8.16% = 0.96

The trade-off: rebalancing gives up $5,719 of carry (โˆ’6.8%) to take $7,197 off average risk (โˆ’8.1%). Second half alone: carry โˆ’11.5%, risk โˆ’13.9%.

Itโ€™s close to a wash on carry per unit of risk (the impact of the curve shape is key to the comparison). But you are holding more risk into the final months so even if the risk-reward is similar the net has changed.

A wrinkle that may lower the risk

Oil put skew generally looks like equities, with OTM put implied vols trading at a premium to the OTM call IVs.

This is the 30-day .25 delta risk reversal for USO (purple line). Notice how the puts went to a large discount relative to the calls in 2026 as the skew inverted.

The further you go out in time in the futures options, the more typical the skew becomes with 1-year OTM puts trading at a premium to equivalent delta OTM calls. This makes sense as both longer-dated futures and options surfaces will reflect producer hedging flows.

The war has created a spot up-vol up regime. This is a noisy fit, but itโ€™s good enough to take us where we are going.

We estimate an elasticity or beta to how much realized vol changes for changes in USO by regressing ln(USO 21-day realized vol) on ln(USO price) over 11 non-overlapping blocks. This yields a slope of 1.06.

So what happens if oil drops 20%?

  1. Your starting $200k oil position falls 20% โ†’ $160,000

  2. If price falls 20%, vol falls approximately by 20%*1.06 or 21.2%. 30% -.212*30% = 23.64%*

  3. Oil $ risk = $160,000 ร— 23.64% = $37,824

  4. ฯƒโ‚š = โˆš(60,000ยฒ + 37,824ยฒ + 2 ร— (โˆ’0.20) ร— 60,000 ร— 37,824) = โˆš(3.60B + 1.43B โˆ’ 0.91B) = โˆš4.12B = $64,210 = 6.4% of $1mm (vs 7.6% base)

Whether itโ€™s this example or any asset in which spot and vols are positively correlated, be aware of how this amplifies risk to the upside and dampens it to the downside. In this example oil $ risk scales with price ร— vol โ‰ˆ priceยน ร— priceยนยทโฐโถ โ‰ˆ priceยฒ

In other words, if the asset increases by 10%, your risk increases by ~1.1ยฒ or 21%.

If oil moved ยฑ20% in the early part of the holding period, then your portfolio vol would be 6.4% (down state) or 9.6% (up state) of $1mm (base 7.6%).

If the move happened in the last month of the 1-year holding period, the respective change in portfolio vol ยฑ20% is 8.6% (down state) vs 17.1% (where the base is 12.2%)

The asymmetry works to your advantage. An oil rally both enlarges the leg and raises its vol, so risk accelerates when the position is winning and vice versa.

*Why approximately?

Start from the fitted line:

ln(vol) = a + 1.06 ร— ln(price)

Step 1: turn the log side into a power.

A rule of logs: b ร— ln(x) = ln(xแต‡).

โ†’1.06 ร— ln(price) = ln(priceยนยทโฐโถ)

and the line becomes:

ln(vol) = a + ln(priceยนยทโฐโถ)

Step 2: raise e to both sides.

Since e^(ln x) = x, this undoes the ln:

e^(ln(vol)) = e^(a + ln(priceยนยทโฐโถ))

The left side is just vol.

Step 3: split the right side.

A sum in the exponent becomes a product: e^(x + y) = eหฃ ร— eสธ.

โ†’ vol = eแตƒ ร— e^(ln(priceยนยทโฐโถ)) = eแตƒ ร— priceยนยทโฐโถ

eแตƒ is just a constant; call it C:

vol = C ร— priceยนยทโฐโถ

Step 4: compare two prices.

Write it out at todayโ€™s price and at a new price:

  • volโ‚€ = C ร— Pโ‚€ยนยทโฐโถ

  • volโ‚ = C ร— Pโ‚ยนยทโฐโถ

Divide the second by the first. The C cancels:

volโ‚ รท volโ‚€ = Pโ‚ยนยทโฐโถ รท Pโ‚€ยนยทโฐโถ = (Pโ‚ รท Pโ‚€)ยนยทโฐโถ

Step 5: rearrange.

volโ‚ = volโ‚€ ร— (Pโ‚ รท Pโ‚€)ยนยทโฐโถ

Plug in oil down 20%: volโ‚€ = 30% and Pโ‚ รท Pโ‚€ = 0.8, so

volโ‚ = 30% ร— 0.8ยนยทโฐโถ = 30% ร— 0.789 = 23.7%

A word on taxes

  • TIPS in the IRA: inflation accrual is taxed yearly in taxable (phantom income).

  • CL futures: Section 1256, marked to market Dec 31, 60/40.

  • Losses donโ€™t net across accounts.

What we learned

  • Inverse-vol sizing takes three steps: add the vols, take each legโ€™s share of the total, then invert. Vols of 7.5% and 30% give an 80/20 split.

  • A high-carry, negatively correlated asset can be nearly free in risk terms. 20% in oil took portfolio vol from 7.5% to 7.6%.

  • Each futures expiry is its own underlying. Because of the Samuelson effect, a long-dated contract picks up vol as it ages, so a position gets riskier on its own. Portfolio vol went from 7.6% to 12.2% over the year, and oilโ€™s share of the risk from 50% to 85%.

  • Carry and risk are both back-loaded. The 1.12 reward-to-risk at inception spreads the roll evenly and freezes risk at day one. Over a full year of holding, itโ€™s about 0.95. Thatโ€™s still well above TIPs alone (0.70).

  • A legโ€™s share of risk isnโ€™t its share of dollar vol. The correlation term is split between the legs, which is how oil reached 64% of portfolio risk by month 6.

  • Rebalancing is a trade-off, not a free lunch. Trimming oil back to equal risk at month 6 gave up 6.8% of carry to cut average risk by 8.1%: about the same efficiency, but less risk going into the final months.

  • When vol rises with price, dollar risk scales with roughly priceยฒ. With an elasticity of 1.06, a 20% oil rally takes portfolio vol from 7.6% to 9.6%, while a 20% drop takes it to 6.4%.

  • Account placement. TIPs go in the IRA to avoid tax on phantom income; futures go in a taxable account for 60/40 treatment.