I want to share a thought that’s been swinging through the vines in my skull.
A little background.
About every 6 weeks for the past 5 years or so I grab dinner with 2 close friends at the Hillstone in SF. The restaurant fits like an old t-shirt from my NYC days when it went by Houston’s. This regular dinner is one of my most cherished rituals. The 2 friends have traded options for longer than I have at this point. One is still very much in the trenches, he has too many kids to ever retire. The other retired from a long career that focused on the SPX and VIX options complex. Today he runs the college admissions service that my family and friends either use or will be using.
You know how dinners like this go if you’re my age. Some time reminiscing, some time solving the world’s problems, which includes everything from markets, politics, what’s going on under the hood in single stock vs index vol surfaces, current AI workflows, the future of our children, and always the shitshow of anything related to college. (There’s also a healthy dose of sports and what concerts we’re eyeing).
It’s a GenX salon with the deviled eggs followed by a kale chicken Caesar and washed down with an NA pilsner (for me anyway…the bill confesses wine for them). Setting aside my dream of starting a holding company for all our dumb ideas, Hillstone LTD, I always come away from these dinners ruminating.
The recent one was no different.
When I got to the restaurant, while waiting to get seated it was just me and the current trader who was also my biz partner for most of my pro days. You spend about 15 years arguing over trades 20x a day, and whether you take my word for it or you violently agree because the nature of your work leaves you mentally bare to a trusted colleague, you know each other better than you know your spouse. I forget the trigger, but I said something in a passing way while making a wider point. The passing comment was “we should have taken way more risk”.
Even though we never really explicitly discussed that, he replied in a way that indicated that he thought that was true with the same certainty that one has about the sky being blue. He didn’t pause and say, “what do you mean, we didn’t take enough risk?”.
With the benefit of time, this was just so obvious to us that the fact blends in with the rug. Not able to let the obvious be obvious I had to question if this was just survivorship bias but I think where we landed on this is just another version of something I wrote in A Former Market Maker’s Perception of PFOF describing what I think set SIG apart from many of the firms on the floor:
It started with skill and luck. The early big bets on talent and technology meant they were bringing guns to a knife fight. SIG wasn’t known as the “evil empire” on the Amex just because of the black jackets we wore. They understood the risk-reward was completely outsized to what it should be 25 years ago. They were amongst the first to tighten markets to steal market share. They accepted slightly worse risk-reward per trade but for way more absolute dollars. They then used the cash to scale more broadly. This allowed them to “get a look on everything”. Which means you can price and hedge even tighter. Which means you can reinvest at an even faster rate. Now you are blowing away less coordinated competitors who were quite content to earn their hundreds of percent a year and retire early once the markets got too tight for them to compete.
SIG was playing the long game. The parallels to big tech write themselves. A few firms who bet big on the right markets start printing cash. This kicks off the flywheel:
Provide better product –> increase market share –> harvest proprietary data. Circle back to start.
The lead over your competitors compounds. Competitors die off. They call you a monopoly.
In short, SIG understood that bookies could get rich on much less edge than they were getting on trades at a time when volumes were exploding (late 1990s), but the broader investing world hadn’t caught on to just how lucrative the risk-reward was. Nothing attracts a crowd like ROE, of course, so it would be a fleeting period, but SIG maximized.
I think my friend and I, seeing how much tighter markets have gotten, to the point where Jane Street, with its massive balance sheet and coverage, could sensibly price risk with a linear utility of wealth, and just think of how we’d kick a grandma down a flight of stairs for a penny of edge when we used to make a half-dollar.
But this progression of efficiency is good. But if you find yourself riding an outsize wave, you should make sure to check in with yourself…Am I taking enough risk?
I don’t mean this in the sense of investments in public assets. I’m talking about edges you find that others haven’t caught up to yet. New ways of doing things that you wouldn’t want to shout about. Stuff that is in the gears of your business or industry as opposed to wagers open to everyone. And once you find a loop with an attractive return that can take capital, you push it because eventually your little secret isn’t so secret. Eventually you’re drawing blood from a stone, crushing your learning rate and, if you’re slow to adapt, your sense of hope and growth.
I hope these thoughts feel timely. I don’t know if AI is gonna eradicate us, but it’s simultaneously killing some models and opening up new ones. Get to the right side of the K.
